A Vice President cause the dispute in order to prevent medicine from making a noise to engage a policeman to work as in Shenyang 27 hospitals

A Vice President cause the dispute in order to prevent medicine from making a noise to engage a policeman to work as in Shenyang 27 hospitals
A Vice President cause the dispute in order to prevent medicine from making a noise to engage a policeman to work as in Shenyang 27 hospitals
Shenyang 27 hospitals engages a policeman and prevents the news that medicine makes a noise from spreading as the Vice President, the public opinion is in an uproar. Net friend queries this is " Common right is used privately " ,Also medical circle personage says " Sympathize with and understand " . On July 2, the municipal public security bureaus of Shenyang Municipal Health Bureau, Shenyang hold the engagement ceremony, 27 police in Shenyang will be served as 27 to stay above- third -class hospital security protection Vice President Shen, instruct the hospital to deal with doctors and patients' dispute, prevent the intensification of contradictions, improve the emergency of the accident and handle the prediction scheme. What is interesting is, this is a " voluntary job " ---" count, get the salary duty " . Vice Chief of Guangdong Province department of public health Liao XinBo expresses when being interviewed by South Daily reporter, Guangdong will not imitate, but must further canvass the basic method which solve doctors and patients' dispute, will explore and set up and unify medical responsibility dangerously and the third party mediates the mechanism. The net friend queries the dispute takes place, in which do the Vice Presidents of police stand? Shenyang hospital engages the police to spread in the Vice President's news, the network public opinion is in an uproar: "While handling the dispute, what is their identity? Is it the police or Vice President representing the interests of hospital? " Many net friends think, there is no salary but can be replenished, have " dual identity " Police very difficult while handling the public security case that doctors and patients' dispute initiate " Fair and just in handling matters " . The expert queries even more: "It is originally the police's duty to maintain the civil order, can not fulfil the duty without taking on a Vice President? Police enter the intersection of hospital and leaders, can common right spend while being private, incline, maintain the intersection of hospital and interests, how to guarantee that it is just to enforce the law? " The tenth paragraph of article 22 of " loi de police of the People's Republic of China " stipulates clearly: "The people's police can't be engaged in the profit-generating business activities or employed by any individual or organization. " Philosophical Deputy Director of research institute Zhang SiNing of social academy of sciences of Liaoning Province claims, the police are grasping the special law enforcement right that the public give, represent the national will, it will have fairness that can be spoken that public power only serves all masses. So, this " united by marriage " of judicial power and medical trade Not favoured overallly. "Can attack and cure and make a noise even in short term, but may stimulate the contradictions of doctors and patients instead in the long run. " Too furious that medicine makes a noise that the hospital pour out one's woes, are the police too soft? To the method of Shenyang hospital, many medical circle personages in Guangdong say: " make laughs a bit, but can understand, the hospital is under the pressure of the helplessness! " " too furious that medicine makes a noise now, the police are too soft when making a noise to medicine! " The beginning of this year Guangdong Province " Two Conferences " While discussing in groups, member of the standing committee, Zhongshan, three institute famous experts, Hu XueQiang of dept. of neurology of province CPPCC " blow out " excitedly . He says, though all the notice on medicine makes a noise to maintain hospital order, attacking of Ministry of Public Health, the Ministry of Public Security is stuck in the hospital, but there is no people to carry out conscientiously, " the police generally just show up and keep order. If medicine can not make a noise, they do not manage very much! So will encourage and cure the bluster of making a noise virtually. " Medical matters subject section chief Cai of hospital of a the first, second and third of Guangzhou has spoken a typical case: Last June, there are boys 7 years old to die without treatment in the People's Hospital of second in Guangdong Province, relatives gathered up to a hundred people and burnt the paper money, put the mourning hall at the gate of hospital, it is that medicine that hire make a noise to be many among them, each person " replenishes " every day 60 yuan. Make a noise for one week, alarm the Vice Governor in charge of hygiene finally, convene public security men, Ministry of Health to have a meeting and discuss in person, got involved by public security men finally, the incident can be put down. "If each medicine is at a disturbance of the incident alarm the Vice Governor, Vice Mayor to solve, then what if the hospital still? " Section chief Cai's method to Shenyang hospital is understood. Guangdong explores the pilot third party in Shenzhen mediates" this is like a black humour ", it is method when plant being absurd passive and one! " Vice Chief of Guangdong Province department of public health Liao XinBo expresses while appraising the method of Shenyang, Guangdong should not imitate either. "This one simplified thinking, treat the head when the head aches foot ache, cure foot, appear, cut down the intersection of people and incident, get odd alert school right away as kindergarten, the hospital is engaged in several pieces of alert medicine. " XinBo Liao say we need, think why unwilling to go patient medical treatment determine, go to court " right way " thoroughly ,Will medicine make a noise hire? What's happened to handle the mechanism in our medical dispute? Reporter investigation find patient think fight the medical lawsuit, it is time consuming and long, with high costs, and appraise the result in medical treatment " May not be very just" . Because at present " The technical appraisement office of the malpractice " Set up in the medical associations at all levels of province and city, the mode that the expert appraises that adopt and smoke counterparts, the patient queries " The brother examines the younger brother " , " medicine is protected " . Zhong NanShan, academician of Chinese Academy of Engineering, has revealed, in the malpractice dispute of Guangzhou area from 2003 to 2005, only 39 for 354 applications is identified as the malpractice, the proportion is only 11.02%. XinBo Liao say, the intersection of legal system and society now, public security department should attack medicine, make a noise in accordance with the law, maintain the normal order of the hospital. The hospital has closed-circuit TV that records the detailed course, the public security department should investigate and collect evidence thoroughly, distinguish the intersection of patient and relative and the intersection of job and medicine, make a noise, deal with strictly according to " public security manage the intersection of punishment and regulation " laws and regulations. In addition, Guangdong is planning to popularize " medical responsibility is dangerous " too ,And the judicial department and Ministry of Health jointly establish the third party to mediate the system, dissolve the medical dispute. Shenzhen has already started the people to mediate and participate in doctors and patients' dispute to mediate pilot work in an all-round way recently, determine 12 medical organizations of the whole city such as mountain the People's Hospital in city the People's Hospital, Peking University Shenzhen hospital, south and set up medicine to adjust the room, start the third party and mediate the work. Old Chinese sweet gum of South Daily reporter Cao Sri Lankan


|